The Dinkey Timber Sale Stands to Hurt Tumbling Creek. Take Action!
Logging planned for the upper Tumbling Creek. Red and orange represent a mix of clearcuts and shelterwood/seedtree cuts (where only a few trees are left). Green is commercial thinning and yellow non-commercial thinning. Several more cuts will happen a mile downstream.
The Southern Environmental Law Center, on behalf of the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club, and Knoxville attorney Shelby Ward, on behalf of Heartwood and Tennessee Heartwood, jointly filed a lawsuit in federal court Thursday, alleging that the Forest Service is illegally endangering the soil, forests, and waters of the Cherokee National Forest and hiding those risks from the public.
At stake is Tumbling Creek, a cold-water trout stream running through the mountains of southeast Tennessee into the Ocoee River, popular with local families for fishing, wading, and picnicking. "Deliberately ignoring the disastrous effects of nearby timber sales on similar soils and slopes, the Forest Service recently decided to allow heavy commercial logging along the creek," said officials.
For nearly four years, conservation groups said they tried to dissuade the Forest Service from taking risks on publicly-owned lands, with pictures, examples, and monitoring data to show what could go wrong.
“Dismissing legitimate citizen concerns is the most egregious aspect about this risky, ill-advised logging project,” said Sam Evans, staff attorney and Leader of the Southern Environmental Law Center’s National Forests and Parks Program. “The public came forward and said, ‘we don’t want to see these kinds of erosion problems on our lands ever again,’ but the agency simply refuses to learn from its mistakes. They are sweeping literal dirt under the rug.”
In the 3,700-acre project area near Tumbling Creek, the Forest Service is proposing to sell 534 acres of timber for commercial logging, exposing steep slopes and erosive soils. Conservation groups are worried that soil loss will keep trees from growing on those slopes, as was the case with a recent logging project a dozen miles to the west of Tumbling Creek, and that sediment runoff will harm one of the healthiest watersheds and streams in the area, said conservation group officials.
“It’s not that we just disagree with the Cherokee National Forest leadership about this project; it’s that they refuse to consider any science or data that might require them to do things differently,” said Davis Mounger, cofounder of Tennessee Heartwood. “This pattern of dodging our concerns has damaged the forest time after time, and they have left us with no other options.”
The Ocoee District of the Cherokee National Forest offers recreation, scenic value, and economic benefits. In addition to recreation on Tumbling Creek itself, the area boasts whitewater rafting on the Ocoee River, mountain biking on the Tanasi and Brush Creek trails, and long scenic hikes into the iconic Big Frog Wilderness.
“The public asked for a hard look at impacts from similar logging projects, without which there was too great a risk to move forward with this project as planned,” said Anne Passino, staff attorney for SELC. “The streams near Tumbling Creek are among the last clean waterways in the area--the few spared from sediment pollution--and are a special place for fisherman, local communities and families who visit this area to create memories.”
"The mismanagement of comparable projects in the Cherokee National Forest containing similar slopes with erosive soils have left mountainsides barren, stripped of topsoil and, as a result, unable to support native plant and animal life. The impacts to hunting, fishing, and other recreational opportunities hurt local economies for surrounding communities. And when the Forest Service does attempt to remediate damaged areas, it uses taxpayer money that could be better spent on maintaining roads and trails for access to public lands," said conservation officials.
Local citizens have attempted to raise awareness around timber sales in the past and have condemned the taxpayer dollars wasted trying to remediate them.
“The Forest Service is cutting out the public from the decision-making process that impacts our lands,” said Axel Ringe, conservation chair for the Tennessee Chapter of the Sierra Club. “The agency should at least explain what it has learned from recent mistakes and why it believes they won’t happen again. This lack of transparency makes it impossible for us to trust that logging along Tumbling Creek will be any different than previous projects.”
The Dinkey Sale is located in Polk County near the Georgia border and would have significant logging along upper Tumbling Creek. The cut volumes are high: there is a mixture of clearcuts, seedtree cuts (where the basal area of trees is reduced to roughly 10ft/acre, or about 5-6 trees per acre), shelterwood cuts (leaves a bit more), and thins. These are some steep slopes on sensitive soils. The lower reaches also have thinning cuts along the corridor.
This project will include:
• 230 acres of clearcuts, shelterwood cuts, and seedtree cuts with burns and herbicides
• 356 acres of midstory thinning with burning and herbicides, including merchantable trees
• 444 acres of cut-and-leave midstory thinning
• 1861 acres of prescribed burning that alternate between dormant and growing season burns between 2-5 years “depending on vegetative response”.
- 32 acres of non-commercial thinning
- "extended streamside management zones"- 75 acres of logging of 50% of the canopy along Tumbling Creek. This will be the second tier buffer strip between the creek and the heavy logging along the slope.
- An old logging road will be reactivated across Tumbling Creek at one point, where a deposit of Anakeesta Shale is located. Anakeesta Shale is known to cause acid rock damage where roads have been cut in the past.
- Many of the slopes that will be logged exceed 35 percent in steepness and are highly susceptible to runoff, erosion, and compacting from equipment.
Much of the logging will be on steep Junaluska soils, like this site of a Cherokee timber sale that happened a couple of years ago a few miles to the west. Thin topsoil and sensitive soils of this type can be difficult to revegetate.